View source for "Mary Casal" and "Juno": 1864 - 1930

==="A union between two women could be of a higher type ... than any other"===



===Introduction by Jonathan Ned Katz===
The autobiography of the pseudonymous "Mary Casal," published in Chicago in
1930, presents the extraordinarily frank sexual and affectional life history of an
American lesbian.<ref>This introduction and the selection from Casal are adapted from {{GAH}}, pages 548-556.</ref>  


In a major example of creative, historical detective work, Casal's birth name, Ruth White Fuller, and her last name from an early marriage, Field, were discovered in 2003 by Sherry Ann Darling, during research for Master's and Ph.D theses written at Tufts University, supervised by Laurence Selenick.  See: [[Mary Casal, pseudonym: 1864 - Unknown]]. The latter OutHistory entry includes a bibliography of additional sources.


Born in 1864 and growing up in rural New England (Deerfield, Massachusetts), Casal's book presents a rarely heard early lesbian voice detailing her own history -- from just after the Civil War through the first part of the twentieth century. Her portrayal of the sexual life of her time and place has nothing in common with the asexualized, idealized image of women passed down to us by traditional writers and historians. 


Casal's family was poor; her father had become a farmer after his earlier professional career as a singer ended with the failure of his tenor voice. Her father and a sister are presented as affectionate, her mother as loving -- underneath a frighteningly stern, strict, puritanical exterior. 


The last of nine children, Casal was painfully
aware as a young girl of the tears her mother still shed for three offspring dead
before Casal's birth. Her early "protective" feeling for her mother seems to have
later been generalized into "sympathy," especially for other women.


As young as age three or four (1867-68), Casal liked playing with boys, liked
boys' work, sports, and comfortable clothes, wanted a boy's knife, and a boy's
"large handkerchief." She hated dolls and housework, early developing what she
calls "masculine tastes." 


The discovery that she was not built sexually like her male
playmates distressed her. Although she says she early wanted to be a boy, the desire she describes is to participate in what was then customarily and rigidly defined as the "male role."<ref>Casal, pages 10, 17.</ref>


At age eight or nine (1872-73), Casal recalls rebuffing the sexual advances of a
"hired man." She details the later repeated and successful attempts of an older male
family "friend" to have sexual intercourse with her. She reports numerous other
sexual advances by males, young and old, relatives, neighbors, family friends, and acquaintances.


She describes her fear and confusion as a young girl about how to
deal with these repeated molestations. Her argument for greater freedom of sexual
discussion among parents, educators, and children is based on her own negative
childhood experiences.<ref>Casal, pages 22-23, 27-28, 29.</ref>


Casal's history includes a series of emotional involvements with other females,
accompanied by varied forms of active sexual expression. 


Her first feeling of "love"
for another girl, although unrequited, included physical attraction; it began in
grammar school and lasted for many years. 


Her next love for a "girl friend" began
when she was about twelve (1876), and continued during two summer vacations,
accompanied by kisses, nights spent together "in loving embrace," many verbal
declarations of affection, and letters written during winter separations. 


Her third
love was for a female high school teacher whose embraces and kisses, Casal says. she enjoyed "hugely."<ref>Casal, pages 47, 50, 68.</ref>


Finishing high school at age fifteen (1879), Casal went on to graduate from a
midwestern coeducational university where a brother-in-law was a professor. There she fell in love with the university president's daughter, who "seemed quite happy"
to receive her kisses. 


Casal was also attracted to another musically talented college
"girl friend," but unsuccessfully competed with her amorous brother-in-law for this
young woman's affection. 


The sexual advances of another young woman were met
by Casal with disinterest, as she says she liked to woo, not be wooed. 


During her
second year in college Casal felt a great attraction to Flo, a professor's wife, who
physically responded to the extent of "little kisses and big- kisses" given when Casal
stayed overnight at her friend's home. Although the relationship with Flo apparently
did not develop further sexually, it was for Casal a deep and happy love.<ref>Casal, pages 72, 77,82, 86</ref>


After finishing college, Casal taught briefly in a "little New England school" near
her family's home. 


Disturbed by her sexual attraction to women, and wanting to
have children, as well as to prove herself "normal," at age twenty (1884) Casal says she 
married an old family friend whom she did not love. This marriage, a disaster,
finally ended in divorce. (Two genealogical sources say that Ruth Fuller married Frank A. Field in 1887.)<ref>See Fuller and Sheldon in bibliography at [[Mary Casal, pseudonym: 1864 - Unknown]].</ref>


During the period of her marriage, Casal twice became
pregnant, once by her friend Flo's husband, to whose advances she submitted
specifically with the aim of having a child. Both babies died at birth, and her desire
for motherhood was not realized.<ref>Casal, pages 47, 91,94, 100, 110-11.</ref>


Casal describes moving from one occupation to another at about five-or-six-year
intervals, successful at each undertaking, but feeling a strong need for change.


She
invents a toy, patents it, markets it herself, and becomes a successful businesswoman.


At this time, her earlier emotional involvements with women culminate in
her New York City meeting and taking up life with her great love, a woman she calls "Juno." 


Next Casal runs a small, successful private school in the large studio apartment she
shares with Juno on Washington Square. 


Later she is the secretary in an art gallery
where she daily enjoys the view of four of Corot's most famous paintings. 


She is
successful as a commercial artist-a designer of "Christmas cards, favors, place
cards, and the like." 


Living in the country for a time with Juno, Casal farms and
gardens, enjoying the activity and contact with the earth. 


Both Casal and Juno work
for some years as assistants to a rich, female philanthropist (Helen Gould, the daughter of Jay Gould). While traveling in
Europe, Casal sells an article for "several hundred dollars" to a New York magazine,
and in Paris she works for a religious organization.<ref>The article by Ruth Fuller Field is listed on the bibliography, as is a New York Times story about her work in Paris with the WMCA. See: [[Mary Casal, pseudonym: 1864 - Unknown]].</ref>


Late in her career, Casal
heads a large "fresh air and convalescent home" for youngsters about forty miles
from New York City, said to be run "for the people connected with the East Side
mission" belonging to "one of the richest churches" in the city. There Casal tries
out her own ideas of sex education.<ref>Casal, pages 139. 146. 167, 185, 190, 203, 218.</ref>


Retiring from public life after her love affair with Juno has ended, Casal moved
from the eastern United States to the opposite side of the continent and writes her
intimate life story, published when she was sixty-six.


As the last member of her
large family still alive, Casal explains that she can detail her early life without
embarrassment to any relations. She does not reveal her own identity, however, probably
to protect those of her acquaintances still living. 


Casal's book is, in part,
an early and rare American example of a political-literary genre, the homosexual
(in this case, lesbian) defense. Casal pointedly upholds her "higher type" of sexual emotional
relation as "normal" for her -- and as "normal" as its equivalent heterosexual
counterpart. 


A moving section of her book describes how she and Juno think they are the
only emotionally and sexually involved women in the world until they meet a
fascinating and worldly older woman (whom she calls "Phil" -- short for Philosopher),
from whom they learn they are not alone.<ref>Casal, pages 73-74, 178-82.</ref>


Many of the childhood experiences Casal describes and protests appear today as the tribulations of a young girl in a male-dominated society, for example
sexual advances by males which she felt had to be endured, even submitted to.


Casal is quite traditional in her concept of "masculinity" and "femininity," speaking
of what she experiences as her "dual" "masculine" and "feminine" nature. Her
"feminine" self desires to bear and raise children, and feels "protective," motherly
affection for others, particularly women. What she calls her "masculine" side is
sexually attracted to females, dislikes traditionally "feminine" occupations, activities,
and chatter, and desires to intervene assertively in the world.


In college, Casal
says, she did not join the sororities that sought her membership, and the national
organizations for women never appealed to her. She has, however, "affiliated with
men's organizations, when women were eligible:' and has "enjoyed working with
men in business."<ref>Casal, page 91.</ref> 


Although Casal is no feminist, her primary personal and
emotional concern is for women. Her desire to give pleasure and affection to other
women so predominates that not until her relation with Juno does she allow herself
to receive reciprocal pleasure in sex. That even this strong, independent woman was
a victim of the traditional male-oriented ideology of womanhood is a poignant reminder of its
power.


Casal's autobiography is also written with the explicit aim of breaking that
prudish conspiracy of silence about sex which she found so damaging as a young
girl. She strongly opposes the corporal punishment that often followed adults'
discovery of children's sexual investigations. She is for "reasoning" with children
about sex, for encouraging them to speak and ask questions. She emphasizes the
"tortures of unsatisfied sexual desire:' especially for women, citing the example of a
sister of a relative who went mad from sexual repression; she speaks of other
women suffering the same fate.<ref>Casal, pages 68-69 132.</ref>


While Casal argues for freer sexual expression,
it is a terrifying comment on the sexual mystification of her day that she herself
believes in and propagates a whole series of oppressive sexual shibboleths.
Casal's plea for free sexual expression is contradicted by her argument for
greater control and sublimation of sexual impulses. She thinks that masturbation
leads to physical disease and constitutes a "peril" -- an idea she takes pains to pass
along to the youngsters under her care. She seems to feel that the death of her first
child was connected with her "indulgence" in physical lovemaking with a woman
the night before its birth. She seems to believe in, and be worried about, the
possibility of inherited homosexuality, passed from mother to child. And she is
totally traditional in her condemnation of male homosexuals as promiscuous child molesters.


Casal argues for the separation of love and sex, taking the
philosophical stance that sex is necessarily selfish, while love is altruistic.<ref>Casal, pages 101-02, 115-16, 131, 184, 206, 215.</ref> In a way she never anticipated, the import of her own argument for sexual enlightenment
is emphasized by the awful irony of her own puritanism.


In the selection quoted here, Casal describes her meeting and great early love
affair with Juno. Although this section describes a period of great happiness, she
later details a period of intense sorrow when this love affair disintegrates. Casal is
not defensive about her suffering, however, accepting both her joy and pain as part
of a life rich in experience and deeply felt.


As this section of her autobiography begins, the possibility of selling thousands of the toys she has invented brings Casal to New York City, where she seeks a room in a hotel for "women only", run by a
religious organization.


=Excerpt from ''The Stone Wall'' by Mary Casal=

:When I entered the office to engage a room I found a "fat (un)fair and forty" female smugly sitting at the desk. She turned to me with a typical "Christian" expression on her face, which could not hide the uncompromising, cruel mouth.... One could readily see that she could turn a young girl into the streets of that great city, late at night, and a stranger, because she was not of the faith which would entitle her to a bed and safe refuge. I learned later this had been done many times in this Christian hotel!


:... As I stood waiting for the fat one to wait on someone before me, I saw beyond her, over in the rather hidden corner of the office, a youngish girl sitting on a low stool with her head bowed and over her face the most beautiful hands I had ever seen. She was weeping in suppressed sobs. The tears seemed to be coming from the soul rather than from the eyes.


:When asked what the fat one could do for me, I wanted to say "Please comfort that girl." But of course that wouldn't do in such a holy place, so I told her I would like a room. It was in July, and it hardly surprised me to find my room very warm. I had plenty to think about. I had answered with fidelity all the questions asked me, and had been given a room. I looked about me and was greatly amused by the expensively printed warnings hanging on the walls. I read the wonderful words of Christ also printed and framed, and hung as a comfort to the hearts of the selected, who were of the "right" faith. A plea for charity! I fell to wondering about the young woman in tears. What comfort could be found on or in the fat bosom, when the hard mouth showed how hollow it was, where instead there should have been charity for all.


:Those beautiful hands were before me far into the night. The excessive heat in that stuffy room also contributed toward keeping me awake. I thought little of my discomfort, however, as my heart ached for that girl, whose very hands showed she was out of her sphere. I wondered.


:One was allowed to engage a room for only one day at a time but, in spite of the heat, I was determined to try one more night, all on account of the sobs of a stranger.


:In the morning, I went to the office to see whether my moral status still measured up to the required standard and -- there at the desk sat the girl with the beautiful hands. The tears had been dried and she looked up at me with eyes shining with love and human kindness. 

:Here was one who could not turn away a girl on account of her religion, were she not bound by rules so stern she could not evade them. And even in such a case I was sure she would suggest some way of protecting her.


:Turning to me she asked sweetly what she could do for me, instead of "what did I want." I said I wished to engage my room for the following night. When she found which room I had occupied, she turned to me in astonishment and said: "You are the first woman occupying that room in the summer who has not entered a violent protest in the morning about the heat! I will see that you have a better one tonight."


:My business kept me out until quite late in the afternoon. In acknowledgment of her courtesy in regard to the room, and remembering her anguish when I first saw her, I brought her a bunch of lovely violets when I returned.


:She was just going "off duty" when I went to the office. As she had given me a better room and had had my things moved, she said she would show me where it was, as she was going to that floor. She was greatly pleased with the flowers, and her lovely eyes thanked me more than words. I found my room was directly across the hall from hers.


:Something told me that here was the girl of my dreams. I wasn't looking for her; she just came into my life, and I knew. But how to convince her that she was to be my mate was the question.


:There must be no crude awakening. I knew at once that she was not in her natural environment; that she had been gently reared, but that, through some calamity, she was here making a brave and successful fight.


:While I naturally hated the whole atmosphere of that whited sepulcher, I did not hate this one human being connected with the conduct of its business, so I stayed on, engaging my room day by day and never asking to have it changed.


:[Space added to facilitate reading.]


:Let us call my new friend Juno. We met frequently in the hall, in going to and from our rooms. I had found out her schedule quite by accident, and found I was making my business engagements fit into ones which seemed now of more vital importance to me.


:[Space added to facilitate reading.]


:John Drew [a famous actor] was about to open a new play, and I bought two tickets for the night when I knew Juno was to be free. When I told her, at one of our chance meetings in the corridor between our rooms, that I had the tickets, and asked her to take pity on me, as I had no one with whom to go, she hesitated. She said she had always observed a custom of the house never to accept an invitation to go out with a guest. But she also said she longed to go and, after a little urging, she consented.


:She wore a charming, simple little gown which just suited her. I say "little" simply as a term of endearment, for Juno was taller than I, and had a magnificently proportioned figure. I dressed in my only change from the day suit, in a handsome black tailored suit with a black hat and white silk shirt. I called a hansom when we were away from the hotel, for fear of hurting the feelings of the dames who did not smile on this growing friendship.


:I remember little of the play. By this time, I was madly in love with Juno and longed to put my arms about her and tell her of it. It all seemed so natural and right to me, I inwardly rebelled, of course, against convention which said "it isn't done." Patience was my watchward for success, as I knew more certainly each minute that we were made for each other and that in time she would know it too.


:On the way home, we stopped at a very conservative hotel, where it was permissible and wholly respectable for two ladies to have supper without a male escort. We had a delightful supper and talk, and lingered long, as there had been no "time limit" for her that evening. 


:[Space added to facilitate reading.]


:She told me much about her life before she took the position in which I found her. As I had surmised, she had been brought up in very different surroundings, an orphan. All her brothers and sisters had been married, she was engaged to be herself, and was deeply in love with the man. It developed, however, that there were reasons why she could not marry this man, and she had decided to find solace in hard work. She had also decided that she would never marry.


:After this first evening, which she said she had enjoyed more than anything she had done since she had left her home, we had many little chats and walks together.


:[Space added to facilitate reading.]


:I referred one day to the tears she was shedding the first time I ever saw her hands. She laughingly said she remembered that evening so well. She had heard my voice when I was going through the awful questioning and longed to look up, even through her tears, but she did not dare to with those eyes so red. However, she did go to the register as soon as I had gone upstairs and found out my name. Perhaps she, too, had that feeling that we were to mean more to each other. 


:[Space added to facilitate reading.]


:She then told me why she was so silly that night. This was her first experience in earning her living, as the rich relative who had brought the children up in the most luxurious surroundings had cut them off without a penny when he found that they were contemplating marriage. The occasion of the tears was that some well meaning woman had left the change of twenty-five cents on the desk and told Juno to keep  it for herself! She thought there could be no greater disgrace in life than to have to receive a "tip" from a common woman.  She had no time to refuse it, and she dared not throw it after her -- a woman with so little discrimination.


:Now my way was clear. I felt that if I could win her love, I might bring to her even greater happiness than she had anticipated with the man whom she thought she loved. Furthermore, I would not in any way be interfering with any future marriage plans.


:It was apparent that she thought I was different from any woman she had ever known, and that she was both interested in and attracted by me. We had many long walks together and went often to art galleries and to the theater. Our tastes were much alike, and this comradeship was the foundation upon which I was working.


:My sexual passions were not aroused by my contact with her. I longed to caress her and give some sign of my love, but I could not do so as yet.


:The elderly dames, after the pattern of the one whom I had found in charge of the hotel when I arrived, while they were always polite to me and I feel liked me, were alert in their warnings to Juno about forming a friendship which might interfere with her work. Juno was the only young person on the "staff." They were terrified that I might take her away, for they, as well as everyone else with whom she came in contact, loved her sincerely.


:Juno was entirely out of her element in the place, yet she was doing her work with a degree of enthusiasm sufficient to sap her vitality quickly. The dames had no knowledge of me other than they gained by the questions they asked when I applied for admission to the hotel. They told Juno that, notwithstanding the fact that I was a charming woman, she should be a little careful about succumbing to my charms. In after years we often laughed at these precautions against losing her taken by the dames.


:Our friendship grew. She would often drop into my room on her way to bed, after an evening on duty. I would leave my door slightly ajar so she could see that I was lying on the bed and reading.


:My personal appearance? If someone else were writing about that I believe they would say: She had a wonderful complexion and smooth skin, soft brown hair which curled in little ringlets about the forehead and neck (it is now snowy white, wavy in front and cut in a "boyish bob"), which were white and with correct lines; not too fat (as I am now), artistic hands, also pronounced as capable ones; a figure true to form, of about "size forty" at that time; graceful in all movements; a voice soft and well modulated; speaking good English, enunciating her words easily but clearly, and so on.


:One evening I had loosened my necktie and the collar of my light blue shirt -- a color then quite in vogue -- and was impatiently waiting for my girl to be through with her work and to peep in to say good night and give me the sweet little kiss, as we had progressed to that stage by this time. Very proper little kisses, however.


:My feelings for her at this time were not of an amorous nature. My heart was calling for her as a mate. We were so in sympathy on every subject we touched. We loved the same things in music, literature, and art. The music we heard together stirred her as it did me, with a depth of emotion we hardly understood. I occasionally got glimpses of her passionate and hungry nature and longed to open the gates of pent-up emotion.


:During this rapturous period of wooing, I was occupied in a sort of a desultory way with the large contract for my toy, but I must confess my heart was somewhere else. There were orders enough ahead to keep the home forces busy, so I could wait, as indeed it was in a measure necessary for me to do, in dealing with so large a concern, with all its complicated machinery.


:My other two friends claimed a part of my time, but my heart and thoughts were so wholly taken up with what I knew to be the one whom I had sought all my life, that I allowed no opportunity for a possible resumption of former intimacies with either.


:I was patiently waiting for the right time to declare my love -- until a beautiful foundation of sympathy and companionship could be firmly established, as any wise and normal lover should do.


:Hundreds of little ways came to my mind, day by day, in which to nourish the perfect flower that waxed stronger, and grew and grew.


:The time and opportunity came at last, when I was sure that she not only loved me but was also "in love" with me (but did not realize it), for me to tell her as gently as possible how deeply I was in love with her and what I hoped would be the culmination of this great love -- that we could really belong to each other with a more intense love than she had ever dreamed possible. Of course, she was mystified. My kiss that night was more intense than ever before, and her lips willingly yielded to mine ....


:She was truly worried. She said she loved me madly, but not as she had ever supposed she could love a woman -- even more than she had loved the man whom she was engaged to marry. She wondered whether I really were a woman. I assured her that I was, and a wholly normal one, telling her of my two children, and so forth.


:I talked about our possible marriage. Why not? I had thought the thing out and I argued that a union of hearts and souls  constituted a real union, call it marriage if need be. My experience had shown me that to most men, and very likely to some women, marriage merely meant a legitimized permission to cohabit for the relief of sexual desire.


:To me it seemed that a union between two women could be of a higher type, and creative of a more secure happiness and good than any other. At this time I was convinced that I was the only woman who had ever thought of matters in this way. I am sure my thoughts were far from anything but the highest type of love in all its beauty.


:We decided it would be best for both of us to think things over quietly, before we finally decided to bind ourselves to each other in solemn compact. 


:[Space added to facilitate reading.]


:Having at last concluded the deal upon which I had been working, I found it necessary to go to a city about twelve hours distant by rail. Of course we were to write often. Juno's decision would naturally have its influence upon my future field of action, as she knew. I arranged for flowers and fruits to be sent to her regularly during my absence, and was quite the accepted "lover."


:She had much to consider, too, in making any change such as we had pictured. It would become necessary for her to change or at least to re-arrange her work, so that we could live together. We had planned to have our own apartment, each to go on with some work through the day, but to have our evenings and nights at home to ourselves.


:The parting was hard, for we were very dear to each other and had been together for quite a while, enjoying every minute of our companionship.


:I waited twenty-four hours after arriving before I wrote to her. That had given me time to reassure myself, and she too had been able to think things over. The letter I wrote must have carried to her some idea of the love I felt for her and probably gave her a vivid picture of what our life would be, if lived as one.


:[Space added to facilitate reading.]


:The following afternoon after I had made a very good deal with a large firm in that city, and so kept the home fires burning, I received a telegram from her: "Come, every bit of me wants you," signed with an initial.


:I canceled business engagements for the next day and hustled about to find that, by taking a night boat (a mode of travel I had always hated), I could reach the city early in the morning of a day I knew Juno was to be free. I wired her to be at our quiet and conservative hotel at a certain hour in the morning, and to wait if I were late.


:How it rained all night! I knew, for I walked the covered deck until nearly morning. It was still pouring when, after a short sleep, I resumed my impatient marathon with renewed vigor.


The next chapter continues:


:The boat docked and the rain fell in torrents. I called a cab and gave the driver directions to go to a wholesale florist, anywhere he could find one on the way uptown. It took some persuasion to get the big bunch of violets from the wholesaler, but I did so, and sped away to my love. The wonderful violets alone would have told the story of my love for her, for they personified everything beautiful.


:When I arrived, Juno was waiting for me in the parlor of our hotel, eager, and with a most ardent welcome. After the necessary formalities, we were shown to our room. When we were alone our arms were about each other and our lips met in the first kiss that was a pledge of a great and beautiful love. She loved the violets and, in our enthusiasm, it was rather hard to come to earth and make some plans.


:She had arranged for a free day. That was an important point gained. Then, being both very normal beings, we felt that we must have the breakfast to which we were accustomed. A delicious one was ordered, and we sat and loved and talked and thought. She wondered.


:After the removal of the breakfast dishes, we began to talk of our love. I tried to make her see that for me it was not a passing fancy and that I believed it was a serious matter to her. We discussed all phases of marriage, and I gave her my    views, based on my own experience. She, of course, felt that there could never be a man in her life again. So we decided that a union such as ours was to be could be made as holy and complete as the most conventional marriages, if not more so. 


:I suggested that we read the marriage ceremony together as a sort of benediction to our union. We had built up a firm foundation for our lives in the love we held for each other. Our coming together was not for animal satisfaction. There was a real sympathy of ideas and ideals and, as a by-product, as it were, was to come the physical relief of sex desire. As I always carried my prayer book with me, we very solemnly read the service, and meant every word of it. ... We both believed that I was the only one in the world who desired the love of a woman. The time for mere conversation was over. I found willing response to my caresses.


:She, too, wanted to show her love, as I had mine. At last I had reached the heights of physical love.


:Poets have written and sung of "that day of love" or "that night of love" in words and tones which could not express the bliss of it, so why should I try to do so?


:We lingered and loved and rested, and felt there could be no end to the desires which arose. It was the expression of about twenty-five years of suppression of emotion in both of us. In a sane moment, we dressed and took a long drive and had lunch at a favorite restaurant in the Park, and then returned to our room early in the afternoon. We had to make plans now for the future ....<ref>Casal pages 143-57.</ref>


=Notes=
<references/>

__NOTOC__